Topic on Talk:Astonishing Scratchers Wiki

Jump to navigation Jump to search

There Probably Should Be A Lousy Scratch Media Wiki

22
Becarbone (talkcontribs)

I am not saying I want to add users. But I want to focus on the bad stuff of scratch as well because why not.

One thing that should be on the upcoming wiki is the infamous 2018 NostalgiaSquare era, it’s notorious for causing the channel to be banned in December 23, 2018, and also caused it to be infamously (and to an extent, universally) hated by some scratchers for awhile.

SquirtSquirtle (talkcontribs)

They’re called “ Accounts “ on Scratch, not “ Channels “. But I am okay with you saying it on Talk Pages.

Money12123 (talkcontribs)

Couple of things:

  1. I would recommend naming the wiki Vapid Scratch Projects Wiki, as a reference to the now-deleted Vapid Scratch Studios Wiki.
  2. You can't make it here anymore since reception wikis are not allowed to be created on Miraheze anymore, but you can wait for qualitipedia.cf to start working again for a place to request the wiki.
  3. The 2018 NostalgiaSquare era if anything belongs on TSEW when it is revived on qualitipedia.cf.
SquirtSquirtle (talkcontribs)

Don’t let him make it. It technically breaks rule #24 of this wiki ( Crappy Scratch Projects Wiki existed ), and the last time a negative Scratch reception wiki was made, most of the staff were indefinitely banned from Scratch thanks to a Scratch Team member discovering it ( I wasn’t a part of staff, so I wasn’t banned, but Circley’s now deleted wiki made me learn all of this. ). Though most have been since unbanned, we cannot let this scenario happen again.

Money12123 (talkcontribs)

The reason why those wikis resulted in them being banned is because the pages about users were completely unsourced. It was not criticism, it was starting rumours.

CRAB-2 (talkcontribs)

I remember thinking the wiki was "criticism" lol. It was a fun wiki, but it had to shut down.

SquirtSquirtle (talkcontribs)

( Also, though CSW does not have a bad reputation as Bad Scratch Wiki and Stupid Scratchers Wiki, it is still considered to have a rather bad reputation for it’s pages, and even has a page on Tiresome Wikis Wiki. )

SquirtSquirtle (talkcontribs)

I know that they were spreading rumours. Along with that, due to the bad reputation of these wikis as a whole ( especially due to Bad Scratch Wiki and Stupid Scratchers Wiki, which has completely different staff, with none from CSW, CSPW and VSSW. These two are both widely regarded as two of the worst reception wikis ever created due to some of their pages, with this wiki being dumb enough to have a Griffpatch page, and also two of the worst reception wikis on FANDOM and during the Outcast Network era. ) we should not get them revived.

Money12123 (talkcontribs)

Also, we can ban pages about users.

CRAB-2 (talkcontribs)

It doesn't matter. The scratch team also didn't like the pages about projects and studios. And to them, they don't care, they're gonna automatically think the new wiki is for slander.

Money12123 (talkcontribs)

Alright, fine, at least for now. But I might look further into that later.

CRAB-2 (talkcontribs)

I'd say to not even look further into it either. But thanks for considering to not make it.

CRAB-2 (talkcontribs)

I remember making Vapid Scratch Studios Wiki, and no, I don't want it back.

CRAB-2 (talkcontribs)

Do NOT revive those wikis

Money12123 (talkcontribs)

We're not reviving them, we're making new wikis.

CRAB-2 (talkcontribs)

there used to be Crappy Scratch Projects Wiki.

CRAB-2 (talkcontribs)

Still super similar to the old ones. And it will 99% spark controversy again

Money12123 (talkcontribs)

Why would it spark controversy?

Tali64³ (talkcontribs)

The problem here is the target audience of Scratch. Most of its users are 8-16, and many children overreact to anything negative about them or their creations.

CRAB-2 (talkcontribs)

That's an issue I didn't realize back then. Another reason why we shouldn't make a new CSW.

SquirtSquirtle (talkcontribs)
SquirtSquirtle (talkcontribs)

( If you dislike the page in TWW or TWW in general, that is okay. )